First of all, shopping for the ingredients. This cupcake seemed extremely simple ingredient wise. Remember, I use the box mixes and for this one there were only two additional ingredients besides the box mix; malted milk balls (Whoppers) and malted milk powder. I had NO idea what malted milk powder was, but I figured I'd find it somewhere. My first stop was Food Lion. I looked all over the baking isle. Flour, sugar, brownie mix, cake mix, powdered sugar, cocoa; every kind of ingredient that could be a powder was in this isle, but not malted milk powder (that would make too much sense!) I tried to do some research on my phone while I was in the grocery store, however , when the first website you pull up says you can buy malted milk powder at King Arthur's something-or-other website, I start to panic and thought I might only be able to get this stuff online. So, my creative juices started to flow and I thought, "I can just grind up the malted milk balls into a powder and BINGO; malted milk powder!" Sounds good, right? So, I left the store. But then I realized that those malted milk balls have chocolate on the outside which probably wouldn't grind up so well into a powder. Hm...so I'm at home looking up substitutes for malted milk powder. Somewhere online I read that Ovaltine (the plain kind) is malted milk powder and if I could find that then I would be back in business! I also saw that Carnation made this malted milk powder and they even had a picture of it online. I figured the other local grocery store we have had to have at least one of these items. So, I ventured back out and started down the baking isle, again. Just like before I found shelf after shelf of powdery substances but no malted milk powder. I checked the spice section (yes, I was desperate). Nothing. Then I remembered the Ovaltine. All I had to do was turn around and I found the shelves with powdered drink mixes and then I saw it, "AHH"(insert angel appearance music here), Carnation Malted Milk Powder!! Thank you Harris Teeter!
After that whole search party extravaganza, the actual baking of the cupcakes was easy. You just crush up some Whoppers and throw them in the mix with some of the malted milk powder and ta-da! You have Malted Milk Ball Cupcakes. There was a tip in the book about putting the Whoppers in a freezer bag, and freezing them for about 30 minutes, then using a meat tenderizer to crush up the Whoppers. Super helpful tip.
For the frosting, MAJOR drama. In my last post I complained about how much frosting the recipe made, well this one was almost not enough! Actually, it wasn't enough because I ended up adding some more powdered sugar during the mixing up of it all. The recipe only called for 2 cups of powdered sugar, some butter, some malted milk powder, some cocoa powder, and milk. I didn't have cocoa powder (but it only called for 2 teaspoons) so I just substituted more malted milk powder (hey, it took a lot to find it so I'm going to use it as much as I can!) The frosting was soooo runny! I started adding in more powdered sugar little by little. It started to become slightly more firm (not really, but I didn't want gallons of frosting again). The frosting technique on this one wasn't anything fancy since it calls for crushed up Whoppers on top. AND here is the final product!
Baker says?! The idea of this cupcake sounds super yummy to anyone who loves Whoppers and it is just as it sounds. Super yummy! Of course, reading about all of the ingredients in this recipe leads anyone to believe this cupcake is SUPER SWEET. I have to admit, I almost didn't make it through the one I ate. The frosting combined with the Whoppers IN the cupcake and ON the cupcake make it very, very sweet! As you can tell by the picture, the frosting is running off the cupcake and can make it a bit messy but the frosting can be easily corrected by playing with the ratio of milk to powdered sugar (but the extra sugar is probably what added to the super sweetness of this cupcake).
I'm hoping to be able to give most of these cupcakes away to my neighbors. However, I did contact a local soup kitchen today and asked if I could bring some cupcakes by and she said they would really appreciate it. So at least now my little leftovers will have a home!
Here is the link to the recipe:
Happy baking!